Friday, 13 April 2012

Superboy #8 review and Legion Lost #8 review


If the comics can link up, I reckon the reviews can too. So what have we here, as DC's 'Young Justice' titles start their first official crossover?

First off, Superboy, in which the Clone of Steel faces his biggest threat yet, the teenage powerhouse known as Grunge ... for no reason I can see, unless you link his naff appearance to Nineties musical fads. 

A lackey of NOWHERE puppet master Harvest (aka OddGob - have you seen that mouth?), who showed up at the end of the last Teen Titans, he's a metamorph and immune to Superboy's telekinesis. Never mind a tendency to talk about himself in the third person, this idiot gives Superboy enough information about himself to make speedy defeat a certainty. So much for recruiting Superboy to his nasty gang of Ravagers.

Elsewhere, NOWHERE security wallah Rose Wilson goes even more nuts than usual, thanks to the mental manipulations of another new baddie, Leash. Happily, Teen Titan Solstice is on hand to talk her down. And talk, and talk ... her verbal diarrhoea is worse even than Grunge's.

Butch strong girl Caitlin Fairchild, meanwhile, purloins a shuttle pod from STAR Labs - in order to save innocent lives, she tells the poor working stiffs she nearly kills in the process.  

The issue closes with Superboy, totally knackered by the fight, in a very bad spot indeed as he's thrown to the wolves - or rather, two more Ravagers.

This is OK, in a big daft fighty sort of way. Superboy acquits himself well, using his brains and learning to finesse his TK powers. And he begins to feel a kinship with the Teen Titans, who risked a lot to save him in their aforementioned book. A big problem is Grunge, who's just awful - appearance, personality, dialogue, it's all bad. I suspect someone misspelled 'Cringe'. Equally annoying is Solstice, who witters on in a sub-Raven way. It's like she's in some kind of exposition contest - but she's not the uncontested champion. That would be this gal (click on image to enlarge).
I don't know if Tom DeFalco spent too many years writing books aimed at Marvel's younger audience, but this really is terribly awkward, obvious stuff. Of course, as he's scripting over regular writer Scott Lobdell's plot it's possibly a rush job. Still, editors should be sharpening up the more flaccid lines.

On the other hand, Superboy's internal narration is pretty acceptable, showing him growing as a person and a hero. More of this and less of that, please.

Regular penciller RB Silva is joined by Iban Coello and they're a pretty good match - characters have a certain smoothness without being all-out uncanny, and the action sequences shine. My favourite spans the top of pages two and three, it's simple and effective ... and too long to post here. Have a flip-through the comic, eh? It looks to be that Coello inks his own stuff, with Rob Lean handling the Silva side. Whatever, it works, while Richard and Tanya Horie emphasise the story beats with their varied palette.

The Hories get to use a garish green in one panel, for no reason I can fathom - Rose and Harvest are covered by a globby effect ... presumably it's a story detail that will be explained later.

Shane Davis, Sandra Hope and Barbara Ciardo provide the rather intense cover, showcasing Grunge's ability to change his flesh into other materials. What you don't get is an idea of quite how naff Grunge looks. This may be deliberate.

Over in Legion Lost, more NOWHERE men appear, attacking the time-stranded Legionnaires. And it's not like they were having a quiet day, what with the usually placid Tyroc blasting Timber Wolf for nicking cash from drug gangs. Storming off, Timber Wolf is attacked by sword-swinging Rose Wilson - busy girl - and chubby cyborg Psykill. 

Back at the hotel, Tyroc, Chameleon Girl, Gates, Tellus, Wildfire and Dawnstar face agents of NOWHERE 'glorying' in such names as Misbelief, Windstrom, Crush and Hammerfist. There's a big one, a stretchy one, a windy one, a generic one ... oh, hang on, they're all generic. They fill a few pages, though, allowing the Legion to show off their power, skills and spirit.

And they allow guest artist Aaron Kuder to show just how well he can draw battle scenes. How well? Awfully. There's one spread in particular, of Rose swooping down on Timber Wolf and his (presumably meant to be) comic relief acquaintance Oz, that's pure comics; there's a fabulous panel-to-panel kineticism even while he varies Rose's poses.
Not all the pages are outstanding - Kuder seems to have rushed through the talkier scenes to get to the excitement, with Tellus and Gates, in particular, suffering. 

DeFalco's scripting again - writing the whole thing, truth be told - and there are some nasty bumps. Chameleon Girl, for example, when surprised by something she believes to be her husband, exclaims 'Colossal Boy' as if they've barely met. And the Ravagers, as I say, are a pretty limp lot.

But let's not forget that it's DeFalco who writes the action moments Kuder draws so well, and he does have a couple of Legionnaires hint at more things going on than we know. Again I say, come on editors, do some editing - do I have to put this phrase on tee shirts before you do something?

Regular Legion Lost artist Pete Woods and interior colourist Brad Anderson supply the cover, an effective spin on an idea we've seen many times.

Superboy #8 and Legion Lost #8, you may notice, have 'The Culling Prelude' banners slapped on 'em, but I'd say we're pretty much already in the Legion/Superboy/Titans crossover leading to the release of new series The Ravagers (heck, the latter two titles have been crossing over since their first issues). I'm not enthused - the characters we've met so far are the very definition of Nineties Throwback - but so long as the individual comics contain plenty of good moments I can likely ride out the overall arc. 

12 comments:

  1. Like you, I've got my doubts about this crossover... but also like you, I've got to admit that those were some pretty smooth action sequences. I'll be happy to see Kuder's work again.

    And, did we know that Gim and Yera were estranged? If we had, I'd forgotten it, and I'm sad to find out (or re-find out, as the case may be).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's the first I've heard about a split, unless I've forgotten something - I could easiy see Geoff Johns setting something like this up (before ripping off Yera's arm).

      Delete
  2. May is going to be big for crossovers. Animal Man is crossing pathes with John Constantine, Frankenstien is running into The Rot, Resurrection Man is in the crosshairs of the Suicide Squad, Blue Beetle with heading to war in Green Lantern: New Guardians, The Culling of course, and the biggest monster of them all being Night of the Owls with all Batman titles (Besides Batwoman) and All Star Western getting caught up in it. May is going to be epic.

    I'm super excited with the Night of the Owls and curious about Resurrection Man Vs. Suicide Squad, but I just can't wait to get my hands on Frankenstein. Sadly, Jeff's last issue, but at least he is heading over to Justice League Dark, where he is adding Black Orchid and Dr. Mist to the team!

    I'm not really interested in this Culling event, but I do wish the writers the best during the event and deliever something good.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Roll on May - even if the crossovers aren't all splendid, it's nearer my birthday ...

      I never knew about Dr Mist and Blackhawk Kid, thanks!

      Delete
  3. Damn you to hell for using the words "Young Justice" and getting my hopes up, Gray! With Scott Lobdell, a crossover with Gen 13, and disappointing scripts married to potentially breakout artists, DC are basically begging for people to mention 1990s Image, but I would defend DeFalco a little, as he wasn't writing "younger" titles for Marvel, he was writing deliberately retro-styled titles which for some reason younger readers found more appealing as trades than regular comics fans did as monthlies. Sounds like he might be having trouble shifting writing gears - unless of course the stiff style is deliberate and DC intend to market their trades towards younger readers as Marvel did with DeFalco's Spider-Girl.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It wisnae me! DC call the teen books Young Justice, but it is indeed a bugger that there isn't a current DCU YJ book in there. Thanks for clarifying the DeFalco business, I could have out that better.

      Delete
  4. Grunge is back?! Don't DC just want to name a book Gen13 and be done with it? I haven't paid much attention to this crossover thinking it was only a Superboy/Teen Titans mixer, now it seems I'm going to at least get a third of it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ah, so Grunge IS a Nineties character ... I'm off to look him up, Ta Dan!

      Delete
  5. Interesting reviews (and I don't know I feel it's strange to have Grunge in Superboy). And it's always great to find another Legion fan. You can check out my blog www.artbyarion.blogspot.com

    I've been reviewing Legion backissues and other stuff.

    ReplyDelete
  6. And great to find another Arion booster. I loved that series, and the modern day mini.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I loved Arion, Lord of Atlantis. DC had a few interesting series in the 80s outside the regular DCU.

    Well, there's more Legion in my blog now, in case you're interested.

    Are there any more blogs about the Legion that you're familiar with?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Arion, you might try Matt's Legion Abstract, there are lots of keen fans there.

      Delete