Supergirl #18 review 

It's Kara Danvers' first prom but it could be the last dance for Supergirl. The extraterrestrial Evolutionist has interrupted the school party and is calling out the Girl of Steel. While Kara slips off to change into her Kryptonian uniform, her friend Ben Rubel steps up.

DEO Agent Ocampo - stationed at the school with orders to learn Supergirl's secret ID - advises Ben to stop being so brave and concentrate on not getting killed. That's when Kara enters the fray, and learns what this new adversary is all about.

She shares her backstory - alien missionaries infected her people, presaging the end of a civilisation. She turned an escape rocket into gravity-negating armour, and devotes herself to stopping well-meaning aliens messing with other worlds. Which is, actually, precisely what she herself is doing right about now.

Kara's too busy defending herself to assail the alien oddball with logic, using a rather cool move to turn the tide. The Evolutionist's telepathy allows Kara to share her own memories, showing just how wrong she is about Supergirl, shocking the being into retreat.

There's no thanks for Supergirl from Ocampo, who parrots the usual DEO orders to give herself up. But Kara isn’t going to give in. And she’s done with fleeing the scene after saving the day. 

Ocampo stands down, Supergirl flies away to reappear as Kara, and Ben offers her a lift home. And they share a moment.

Then a dance. And a kiss. 

Things are certainly looking up for the Girl of Steel, but the close of the book shows another member of the cast having a seriously bad day...

This is a lovely issue. Once again Kara is a shining example of heroism, slow to anger, quick to seek understanding. She uses her powers with real skill. She makes the Evolutionist think again, then confronts Ocampo with the nonsense of her assignment. As Kara she finally opens up a little to Ben. And there's a fine bit of secret identity business as she wakes up on the beach, before Ben, after what I presume was an innocent snooze together. 

The issue isn't without its headscratching aspects though. The Evolutionist follows quickly on the heels of Deceilia as an alien menace who reckons her tragic backstory gives her the right to attack anyone she wishes. The Evolutionist's targeting of Supergirl is more personal, mind, begging the question: why? She's come to a world which is also home to Superman, J'onn J'onzz, the Hawks... why is Supergirl so annoying to her? And what's her motivation, stopping people getting alien germs, or preventing aliens from interfering; her past points to the former being the problem, but her words to Supergirl are all about the latter. 

The fact that she first appeared last issue in an end sequence drawn by a different artist to the one who handled the bulk of the book has me wondering if a planned storyline for this issue was dumped, and the Evolutionist slipped in - not so late that she didn’t make the solicitations a few months back, but late enough that she’s not as differentiated from Deceilia as writers Steve Orlando and Jody Houser might have made her. She’s just another judgemental, angry alien lady. Certainly my nose twitches at the fact she doesn’t appear on the excellent cover by regular penciller Robson Rocha, inker Daniel Henriques and colourist Michael Atiyeh. 

Or maybe I’m just more suspicious even than dastardly Director Bones. 

Talking of suspicions, I’m tickled that Ocampo is convinced Kara's classmate Belinda Zee is Supergirl, that takes me right back to the early Seventies when, if memory serves, Linda Danvers' boss Geoff Anderson suspected Supergirl was frenemy Nasthalthia Luthor.

Rocha is absent this issue but Carmen Carnero keep things looking extremely spiffy with her great-looking, dynamic work. Every page is terrific, but my favourite sequence is her and Atiyeh’s execution of Orlando and Houser’s tribute to the classic phone booth change. 

She also treats us to some excellent facial expressions and body language, especially as regards Ocampo. And whatever the Evolutionist is doing here, Carnero and Atiyeh make her look fantastic - ethereal, slightly whimsical, yet menacing. I hope DC gives Carnero a regular book. 

While Carnero would likely do a fine job with wordless sequences, without words there ain’t no comic, and Houser and Orlando give us a splendid script, well paced with a smart balance between character and action. And it’s all lettered by the excellent Steve Wands, adding another layer of style and craft to the book

There’s a variant cover, by Stanley ‘Artgerm’ Lau, and it’s another stunner, showing Supergirl in my favourite costume, and set about a second after the first issue of her Eighties book. And while that logo was never a favourite, seeing it again has me warm and fuzzy. 

A year and a half in, this Supergirl series has found its feet, with Kara’s perspective on superheroism - open hand first, closed fist if necessary, friendship and rehabilitation if possible - rather unique in the DCU. I dearly hope this book doesn’t fall victim to whatever incoming Superman writer Brian Bendis plans...


Supergirl #18 review, Jody Houser, Steve Orlando, Carmen Carnero, Michael Atiyeh, Steve Wands, Stanley ‘Artgerm’ Lau, Robson Rocha, Daniel Henriques 


  1. I wonder if it was more than coincidence of the variant cover syncing with the content, for in TDNAOS, Linda had decided that she would take a step back, not engage in every emergency, and much to the horror of the Danvers, she was allowing, for example, a fire to be fought by the fire fighters as they could handle it. She was going to learn to live more as the woman she wanted to be, to be as normal as the second most powerful hero in the DC Universe could be. In this issue, at the end, Kara seems to have learned that she can live in a similar manner. It seems like it has taken years to get what Kara understood in the 1980's, when her clones became the singular clone and it caused the Linda and Supergirl personalities to split temporarily - that without an alter ego, only living as Supergirl was detrimental, she needed downtime.

    I'm hoping that how this arc is becoming/ ending isn't a send off to Supergirl, all because of Bendis or poor sales (the latter which could have helped with a different artist early on, actual crossovers with Batgirl (not just a team-up) and The Flash, and better marketing.) After Kara was seemingly incinerated in "Superman/ Batman," fears of her death were softened when DK's DC Encyclopedia's profile for the character had her learning to live as a young woman in a new world. Of course, Kara was popular enough then to gain her own book, so that never happened, but not unlike previous volumes, it seems like when Supergirl finally finds herself - whether Linda Lee Danvers, Linda Danvers, Linda Lang, or Pre-Rebirth Kara - the title folds and the character goes into DC Limbo. Still, I'd rather have a diminshed presence of Kara Zor-El than erased. Bendis loves to change continuity to fit his view of things (for Jessica Drew being one of his favourites, he ignored and erased so much of her history - although he did cause her to be back in the spotlight), and reading that the status quo hasn't been changed so much since Post-COIE, but it will be, it certainly is unsettling to think what lies ahead.

  2. Please God Kara doesn’t get wiped out again. It seems hugely unlikely given the prominence of the TV show and success of other versions of Supergirl. But who knows, DC seems to be worshipping at the feet of Bendis. Expect a campaign from me if she vanishes! With luck Bendis will Be too into Superman to mess with Supergirl. And besides, isn’t he meant to be a big Superman fan? That has to include Supergirl...

    Great work linking the alternate cover to the original DNAoS. DC should totally claim this is the case.

  3. Maybe Bendis will want to make Clark and Kara more family-like. I mean, in the recent Superman book Jon mentions Cousin Kara, but you seldom see the two interacting, and considering she is a young girl, you'd think Lois and Clark would show more of an interest in her like the Earth-2 versions did to Power Girl Kara. I hope so, because I would like to see Kara and Clark develop a close and loving relationship similar to the beautiful relationship they have been portraying between Clark and Jon. I know a son is not the same thing as a cousin, but she is his last surviving true Kryptonian relative.

    1. I’ve certainly said plenty of times that I want to see Kara babysitting Jon and generally hanging out with Lois and Clark; as you make clear, it simply makes sense. I’d love a Super Sons companion book, Superman Family, where such things could happen regularly. Have Lois and Clark, for example, even met the Danvers?

      What I don’t get is folk - and that certainly doesn’t mean you - getting all bent out of shape about it, getting so very affronted on behalf of a fictional character.

    2. I guess for me it's just a matter of the writers not putting thought into it, or maybe they do and editorial shoots them down. I mean, it can't be a continuity issue, since DC seems to have stopped caring bout that at all, and frankly, not every appearance of a character has to be neatly placed in an exact position in time relative to another book. I mean, Supergirl and Superboy could spend three issues together fighting a meta-bully and it would still not mess up the stories in any of the other Superfamily books.

      I guess I just want to see more thought put into some of these characters and their relationships to the other people in their families, especially when the characters in question are not even adults. I mean, don't get me started on Batman's parenting.

  4. I kind of skipped over the Ocampo scene in my review so glad you showcase it here.
    Turning enemies into allies, and sayin she’ll do good no matter how many weapons are pointed at her is pure Kara.

    1. I kind of want to adapt Linda Carter’s WW theme song for Kara, all that ‘turning hawks into doves business’ is terrific.


Post a Comment