Plastic Man #1 review

Can you judge a book by its cover? In this case, I’d say yes. Aaron Lopresti’s image shows a gangster’s moll looking sour as a patsy bleeds out in an alley and wiseguys look back at their handiwork. Plastic Man looms over all.

Inside we get pretty much that same scene, with the absence of a costumed Plas. The shapeshifting sleuth is there, but he’s the victim - Eel O’Brian. The reformed criminal has resumed his old look to draw out the former associates who left him to die after a safecracking job went badly wrong, leaving him with a bullet wound and a security guard dead. Along the way he somehow became ‘some weirdo made of used gum’.  

That same quality means that despite all the cracked bones and blood, Plas survives, to track down the bad guys. 

The Wonder Woman nod is a nice moment, but it’s the only scene I really like in Gail Simone’s script. Simply put, this isn’t the book for me. I realise that back in the Golden Age, creator Jack Cole’s Plas could go to some pretty dark places, and that we’re decades from those days, but I really don’t want a hero talking like this. 

There’s also a running gag involving a slang word that isn’t so much near the knuckle as somewhere a little more private, a suggestion of super-manhood and a general sense of sleaze that isn’t for me.

Adriana Melo is an artist I’ve enjoyed across many a DC book but her art doesn’t suit Plastic Man. Plas requires a smooth approach, and Melo seems uncomfortable drawing the character. 

Which is a shame because everything else in this first issue looks great, even Plas when he’s in civvies. And while I don’t like the subject of one such sequence - the gangsters brutalising Eel - there’s no denying Melo’s facility with silhouettes. 

She’s aided by the colours of Kelly Fitzpatrick, which capture the urban environment of Cole City, occasionally brightening for dramatic effect. And the letters of Simon Bowland complement the art nicely. That cover by Lopresti is well done, for what he’s been asked to draw, while the variant by illustrator Amanda Conner and colourist Dave Johnson evokes the fun book I’d like to be reading.  

Simone sets up an intriguing storyline involving spy organisation Spyral and possible corruption within the big super-teams, so I may be tempted back, but right now I’m not committing to this six-issue mini-series. Plastic, yeah. But outright tacky? No thanks. 


Plastic Man #1 review, Gail Simone, Adriano Melo, Kelly Fitzpatrick, Simon Bowland, DC Comics 


  1. I'm really surprised. I enjoyed this immensely, and while Eel's raunchiness at the beginning is a little harsh, this seems to be set just after he became the pliable sleuth, so I chalk it up to not yet divesting himself from his past. These are the people he palled around with, anyway. Looking forward to seeing how Adriana Melo works in Plas' skill at disguising himself as common objects.

    But I'd say the first issue is wang!

  2. Glad you liked it. Wonder if Plas will get ‘shinier’ as he goes on. And whether that kid has anything to do with anything. And whether wang means anything beyond the obvious.

  3. Yeaaaah, not for me either. I definitely agree with you Martin about the poor choice of artist. This series really needs more of a cartoonish, but classy look to it, like the cover artist, Amanda Conner. My other choices, besides Dave Johnson, would be either Doc Shanier(he's already busy) or even Martin Marcos or Paolo Rivera. Hell I'd even take Todd Nauck. Hopefully they switch artists and get to the good stuff that Simone's more than well-known for.

    1. Some great suggestions, and if the writing gig opened up I’d love Doc Shaner’s old sparring partner Jeff Parker to write it.

  4. Well, I thought it was wang. I agree that Eel's insult in the opening scene in harsh, but at that point he's a criminal among criminals that he's known for a long time -- he knows how to get under their skin. He's playing the part of who he was, and that includes the salty talk.

    The infiltration plotline has me curious, but even without it, I'm enjoying seeing Plas in action.

    1. I see your thinking, Rob, but it still seems unnecessary.

    2. I don't see it as necessary, per se, but it still seemed like a valid choice to me. Definitely not a dealbreaker for me.


Post a Comment