Justice League of America: Rebirth - The Atom #1 review

It's Ryan Choi's first day at Ivy Town University. His parents have accompanied him all the way from Hong Kong. They're kinda clingy. 
But adorable. 

Soon, Ryan's smarts have caught the attention of his idol, physicist Ray Palmer. A year later, Ray calls him to his office to answer a question. 
Ryan comes up with the response that satisfies the professor, and he's made an offer

And the next year is spent acting at the Atom's second, monitoring Ray while he's off adventuring at six inches, one inch, microscopic size. But one day, Ray vanishes...

You don't have to be familiar with Ryan's previous continuity adventures as Ray's superheroic heir to guess what happens next. The issue closes with Ryan ready to take up the mantle and find his mentor. 

I like this opening chapter a lot, and rather wish it were the lead-in to an ongoing - or would a mini be more appropriate, ho ho? - rather than simply his membership in the upcoming Justice League of America book. I want to see more of his parents... hey, they could move continents. I want to see his solo adventures as the new Atom. I want to see more of his roommate, Adam Cray, who's as allergic to shirts as Ryan is to dust. 
I suppose Ryan's asthma explains the mask he wears as the Atom, if you're going small, dust is going to be a big problem. 

Explain, yes, excuse, no - that is one horrible 'update' to the classic Gil Kane costume. Previously, Ryan wore a suit similar to the original, yet it was all his own, and he looked great. This TV-influenced look, though, is clunky as all-get-out, just awful. It's ironic, the Legends of Tomorrow producers would likely love to get away with the skintight look; comic books actually can, and should. Ray looks a thousand times better in his short appearance in traditional garb than does Ryan on this cover and in the preview art released by DC.  

As for Ray, I don't believe he's really lost, I reckon this is him teasing out the heroism he suspects is in Ryan - he'll be off on a sub-atomic beach, being served tiny cocktails by a blue-skinned wench. 

Thinking of Ray's loincloth days, when he became a mini-Conan the Physicist, there's a reference to it on the first page. 
I'm confused. Here's Ryan atop Ryan's specs, in a scene recalling the Sword of the Atom mini-series from the Eighties, yet Ryan hasn't even met Ray at this point. Is it part of the daydream his parents mention? That's one very specific/prophetic image given he won't become an Atom for three years. 

Longtime fans likely did a double take when I mentioned Adam Cray... yep, that's the guy who was the temporary, Suicide Squad Atom when Ray faked his death. I suspect he's working with Ray to mould Ryan, as he seems to be stealth training Ryan in physicality as Ryan observes Ray's heroics. 
I may be overthinking. It could be a mere nod to old continuity. Lord knows, I get overexcited at the mere mention of Stanhope University, Linda Danvers' Silver Age college. Not coincidentally, Steve Orlando - writer of this comic and, soon, the JLA - is handling the current Supergirl book. Here, he does a splendid job of making the characters likeable and the situations intriguing. As I said, I want more, especially if he'd give us the wacky Ivy Town created by Grant Morrison and Gail Simone. Goodness, that had aliens and Lady Cop!  

This issue is billed as a DC Rebirth book and fulfils the mission statement in returning to us a Ray Palmer who's lived through his Silver and Bronze Age tales, married and divorced Jean Loring and come out the other side. I love that, and Ray has always been a favourite, so while I like Ryan, I don't want Ray sidelined right out of the stories. 

Where the Rebirth doesn't seem to be in operation is with Ryan - so far, he's a nice guy, super-clever, but noticeably less fun than the previous version. It seems more like he's being New 52ed than Rebirthed, that is, tweaked unnecessarily. And the previous Ryan was returned to continuity just last year in Convergence, so why not pop him back into New Earth society? Still, there are signs of life, especially at the end, and Orlando is ruddy good, so I shall reserve part of my judgment. 

I don't think I've seen Andy MacDonald's art since DC's intermittently entertaining Future's End series and I'm glad to see his work here. His slightly rough-edged line is reminiscent of the late Steve Dillon's, and he's a whiz with body language. Just look at the way Ryan is sliding backwards as Ray lunges at him.  
Bring on the monthly, and give him the regular job, along with colourist John Rauch and letterer Clayton Cowles.

MacDonald and Rauch also provide this issue's alternate cover, which I prefer to the mass market affair by Ivan Reis, Joe Prado and Marcelo Maiolo because it's recognisably the new Ryan. Neither image, sadly, gives us any sense that this is a tIny Titan - yes, he's swimming among atoms or protons or something, and standing on what must be a wee menacing monster, but if you don't know.... plus, he's huge on the main cover, filling almost all the space. 
Quibbles aside, I enjoyed this one-off massively, from the arc of the story to small details such as the name of Ryan's hall of residence. Let's hope the other three Justice League of America: Rebirth specials - Vixen, the Ray and Killer Frost - are as good. 


  1. Ryan's costume aside, this was a fun issue. I'll be skipping JLA so I hope he shows up in one of Orlando's other books...

  2. I am not a big Atom fan (no pun intended) but enjoyed this. This was a true origin story for Ryan, explaining why he would be interested in being the Atom and why Palmer would want him to be the Atom.

    And having the 'less than imposing looking' nerd as a hero is something I can always get behind. I loved the double page spread with classic Atom pics (bottling that guy like in Showcase) and Ryan's slowly growing confidence. Very nice.

    I don't know if I am going to get Orlando's JLA. But this made me more interested.

    1. I'm a lifelong Ray fan, I loved his original Silver Age tales, his shorts when Enrichetta was around, his travails with that hussy Jean, the refreshing Power of the Atom, heck, even his Teen Titans spin was fun. As I said, I like Ryan, but Ray is the Atom I want to read about.

  3. Armour looks stupid. Really forced and moronic. Still love the Atom, though.

    1. I wonder who came up with the design? Break their stylus!

  4. the armor looks cool to me an Ryan will probably grow into the hero u guys remember I just hope he an Giganta hook up again

    1. Ah Giganta, I can't even remember the last time we saw her outside of a Wonder Woman short stories.

  5. As pleased as I am with Rebirth, DC continuity continues to be a mess.
    So Ray Palmer's Silver/Bronze/more modern adventures are back after being jettisoned during the New52, but Ryan's relatively new past dating back about ten years has been rebooted. And over in Blue Beetle, meanwhile, Ted Kord has some parts of his origin intact apparently, but Dan Garrett, the original Blue Beetle, has been rebooted, as has the newest Beetle, Jaime Reyes.
    As a DC fan I've certainly gotten accustomed over the years to a flexible use of continuity. Some writers drop bits and pieces, only for other writers to revive them. But this just is getting a little absurd. I don't know why Ryan has to be this brand spanking new Atom
    And even more head scratching is that this is all going down within the context of the over-arching Rebirth plot about Dr. Manhattan (or someone) having created the New52 by messing with the pre-New52 continuity. So it feels like all of these "new" origins for characters like the new Atom and the new Beetle are suspect/flimsy anyway.

    1. I think, as Hector says below, we're deep in a Rebirth territory. I don't mind people having different bits of their continuity back, so long as there's a plan, and a spreadsheet, and everyone has a copy; how many times has a Crisis or a Zero Hour claimed to be sorting continuity, and within a year we're knee-deep in contradictions?

  6. I was a bit confused by the atom fighting off the germ thingies, but I think it may be a clue as the multiversal nature of the Atom story that is about to happen in JLA. Also, Ray Palmer did disappear, it was part of Rebirth, with speculation being that he has been caught by whoever has Red Robin.

    I, personally, think that he is caught in the Microverse because it has become unsynched with the rest of the Multiverse as a result of the meddling in it and the timelines. Also, as for the Rebirth continuity being a mess, I think, and maybe that is me being overly optimistic, that mess is part of the point. The Rebirth world seems to be slowly merging backward with the pre-flashpoint world, and that means crazy continuity glitches, as is being explored in Wonder Woman.

  7. 'Merging backwards', I like that, Hector. I remember the Rebirth Special had the last few pages of this issue, but not speculation about (as it turns out) Mr Oz having him. Have I got to go back through all those pages? :)


Post a Comment