Action Comics #972 review

It's Superman and Luthor's last stand, but it's not against one another - they're united against L'Call and Zade. The alien powerhouses want to execute Lex for crimes they believe he'll commit. Superman has crossed light years because he won't condemn a man in the belief millions of lives will be saved - he knows the future isn't fixed, that a person can change. 

And he isn't even sure this Lex needs to change. Since arriving on a version on Earth not his own, he's tested his assumption that any Lex is a bad Lex, and found no proof. So he gets the benefit of the doubt. And Superman, trapped under a red sun, is willing to die to defend his point. 
Just as Superman has been giving this Lex a chance, his own actions are wearing down Lex's assumptions about him. 

And in the end, it's Superman who stops the fight, not with his fists - well, not entirely - but with reason. By the close of this great-looking, smartly written conclusion to the Men of Steel arc, he and Lex come to an understanding. It's a new dawn. 
I'm torn. Lex is my favourite Superman villain and I'm really tired of the good bad guys turning anti-hero, or even good. On the other hand, some of my favourite Lex stories, back in the Silver and Bronze Ages, involved him being forced into the position of hero and eventually trying to be a better man. And he was originally Clark Kent's best friend - would Lex being good be bad? 

Besides, it's not like he can't embrace the nasty after his shot at redemption...

This issue also sees the doppelgänger Clark Kent discover that Lois has a young boy hanging around her, one who looks a lot like her... she needs an ingenious explanation if he's not to guess she's Jon's mom. 
Meet Lois Lane, Pulitzer Prize winner... that'll stop Clark being suspicious. Mind, he could never be as suspicious as he looks, courtesy of penciller Stephen Segovia, inker Art Thibert and colourist Ulises Arreola. 
Good grief. And who knows, he may not be bad, he may just be drawn that way - it's not like writer Dan Jurgens isn't a wily soul. He certainly teases us with a closing splash that's full of foreboding. 

Jurgens, Segovia, Patch Zircher and their colleagues have produced a cracking epic spotlighting the Superman/Luthor conflict across time and space. Pull out the Clark subplot and it'd make a fine DC animation adventure. I can't wait to see what comes next. 

Inker Art Thibert provides this issue's main cover - I don't recall the last time I saw pencils and inks from him, and I really like this poster-style illustration, which is nicely coloured by Steve Downer. 
And then there's the variant cover by Gary Frank and colourist Brad Anderson. If DC don't blow this joyful piece up and make it a mural at their Burbank headquarters, they are crazy (and a Josh Middleton DC Rebirth Aquaman cover wouldn't go amiss, either). 

New characters with potential, new perspectives on old characters, and of course, plenty of action - Action Comics Weekly may not have caught on way back when, but Action Comics fortnightly? It's win all the way. 

Comments

  1. I'm torn on Lex myself. I didn't read the New52 Superman books, but I did read Forever Evil and, from what I recall, Lex intentionally let Ted Kord's dad fall to his death. So he lied to Superman last issue when he said he did not rescue Kord in time. Either that or DC is revising what happened.
    And is it the case that, during the course of the New52, Lex has never done anything publicly evil? This claim Superman (and Jurgens) keep making that Supes investigated Luthor and could find nothing just doesn't seem to hold water. But again, I didn't read the Supes books so maybe that is consistent with how his character was portrayed.
    Also what makes all of this even more problematic is that DC really never did make it clear what Pre-New52 stories happened/hadn't happened. Lex did a lot of bad stuff pre-New52. So now we're supposed to accept that none of it happened in the New52? It just seems weird that Supes came up with zilch. Seems more like editorial convenience for the sake of this story.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Very fair points, but the very fact that we don't know so many facts allows me to forgive myself for just going with it. We may have had another soft reboot with DC Rebirth...

      Delete
  2. To clarify: Since we began the New52 five years after superheroes debuted, there was always a question as to what pre-New52 stories occurred during that time. DC never really went out of its way to try and clue readers in. So my point is that it seems like Lex has a pretty rotten reputation in the superhero community and must have done some bad stuff. So the idea that the pre-New52 Supes isn't aware of any of it is just hard to swallow.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's a very fair point. I miss the days when we could assume we'd see all of a character's significant adventures.

      Delete
  3. Lex Luthor is portrayed as a villains in Superwoman. He tried to kill N52 with a virus that became Amazo. He blackmailed his way onto the Justice League. Why does anyone want or believe he is going to reform?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm not letting the Superwoman Lex into my mental canon, all that guff about him needing Lena to get his big breakthroughs? Nah!

      Delete
  4. We all know a future regime will have Luthor break bad so if the stories of a more heroically inspired Lex are good, let's just enjoy them for now. What bothered me about this arc was how drawn out it was. Doomsday was the same. They both took way too many issues to cover way too little ground. It's not a semi-monthly thing since the other semi-monthly titles I follow haven't been dragging. Maybe Jurgens needs some help actually coming up with enough story to fill the faster paced publishing?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh, that's interesting. I've not found them draggy at all.

      Delete
  5. Overall I thought a very good issue. But two quibbles held it back from being spectacular.

    1) While Jurgens deserves major respect for making me consider this Lex as a hero, it flies in the face of what is happening right now in Superwoman. I can fuzz out in my mind things that happened pre-Rebirth but these are two concurrent stories with two very different takes on Lex. Where is the group editor?

    2) Why would Lex/Supes think splitting up would work when in the very first pages Zade/L'call say they don't care about Superman and only want Lex? And why would Zade go after a depowered Superman if Lex is the target. Seemed tough to reconcile.

    Still, I thought this 'fresh start' and Supes/Lex looking at their own biases was very interesting.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I was having a think about that splitting up thing and decided that they'd have two moving targets and wouldn't know which is Lex until.. I know, I know...

      Delete
  6. Also, pre-New52 Superman's now a member of the Justice League. If I recall under Geoff Johns Batman and Wonder Woman and New52 Supes were preparing to, somehow, take him down, then he blackmailed Bruce into joining the League. Doesn't pre-New52 Supes know this? Shouldn't there have been some scenes with him talking to Batman and Wonder Woman about their thoughts on Luthor, particularly since Luthor was on the League not too long ago?
    This really speaks to a quibble I have with Jurgens' current Action run. In some ways it really does seem like he is out doing his own thing and no editors are bothering to try for consistency with other books in the Supes line or with the wider DCU. Jurgens continued Geoff Johns' Luthor-gets-a Mother Box plot thread, but seems to have ignored any of the crap Luthor pulled in Forever Evil and the Justice League issues in which he forced himself on the team.
    There really is no reason why pre-New52 Supes would suddenly be so accepting of Luthor, other than that's what Jurgens wants to happen.
    While I'm thinking about it, what ever happened with that little nugget that Luthor had figured out Bruce Wayne is Batman?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There was a scene somewhere with Luthor turning up at Wayne Manor demanding to see Batman... I don't recall what happened next!

      Delete
  7. Should specify "take him down" meant take Luthor down, then he blackmailed his way onto the League.

    ReplyDelete
  8. New 52 Lex (which is to say, this one) has certainly done some despicable stuff. But I'm happy to see him try to turn over a new leaf, as he seems to have been doing in fits and starts since Forever Evil. I don't think it'll take, but I hope they show him trying, as various parts of his unsavory past catches up with him. A complex Lex is a fun Lex to read about.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Very true. Now, if only they ignore that Geoff John's version of Adora... along with the stupid business a Diana having a brother named Jason.

      Delete
  9. Great review Martin! Jurgens certainly is an under appreciated writer.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanks, if DC has a Hall of Fame, Jurgens certainly deserves a place in it.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment